Monday, 23 April 2012

Lecture 8: Is this Ethical?


Today we had a guest lecturer, Dr Harrison, and he introduced the topic of ethics by drawing our attention to some ‘controversial’ ad campaigns. As he showed them to us we were asked to rate each on a scale of ethical to unethical and also whether they were in good taste or were downright tacky. After this activity he then asked us how we judged the ads on that scale. What makes things good or bad? What makes an output of media ethical or unethical? Who judges the difference between right and wrong?

Giving my personal answer of how I judged and how I think others judged the variety of ads, I’d say it was all about my personal values and what I was taught growing up to deem right and wrong. Take for example the Sam Kekovich ad that was shown. I find that ad to be in pretty poor taste. I wouldn’t say it is to the degree of being unethical but I certainly don’t think the creators focussed on making an ethical ad. Some of the statements and just the general…atmosphere, I guess, that the ad creates doesn’t appeal to me in any way. I know it’s a different story for many other Australians, because as Dr Harrison said, the ad has become somewhat of a legacy.

 












To relate this back to journalism he discussed three ethical theories which were:
  • Deontology
  • Consequentialism
  • Virtue
Deontology is the one that follows rules and principles. These rules are external to the individual so all ethics codes on journalism, advertising, business, etc are deontological. This theory requires little independent thought and no strong character values because as long as you can comprehend the rules and stay within the guidelines you’d be fine.

Consequentialism focusses on the idea that all that matters is the outcome. It doesn’t matter how, for example, a piece of journalism was uncovered as long as it was ‘for the greater good’. This one seems a bit dodgy I think, as so many things could be conducted poorly throughout the process. But then again how can you define what ‘poor conduct’. I guess that is the very essence of this theory, nothing is deemed wrong along the so long as the final product will benefit the majority.

Virtue ethics is what Dr Harrison said was essentially, the most important theory type to understand when it comes to being a journalist. Sure, it isn’t what the journalists’ codes are about, but the very backbone of this theory is that “goodness” comes from good habits of character. Courage, justice, temperance and prudence are all internal values that guide you in your work. Compare these internal values to that of deontology where you are given the guidelines and there is no need for you to think for yourself. In order to be an efficient and truly great journalist these values must be second nature to you and you won’t learn them from memorising any code.



There was a little controversy back in  2011 about whether The Australian had acted unethically when they received sponsorship by a pharma industry group that directly funded their health journalism. The Australian insisted they maintained editorial independence throughout the partnership but it was heavily questioned by others in the media saying that the drug industry having any influence in public discussion was a dangerous thing. There was sympathy though towards the idea that journalism must be funded one way or another, but perhaps it was a poor choice by the newspaper. Crikey goes into more detail here. 

That’s me done for Lecture 8.

Thursday, 19 April 2012

Last post before assessment!

Hello there!

I'm just writing quickly so say what's been happening in the world of college after the mid-sem break. :) Pretty much the over 18s have been going out to the strictly over 18 events, while I've been working hard but tomorrow night is our College Ball! So I get to whip out my prom dress again and get my hair and makeup done all fancy, invited a lovely boy to attend with...but I have an economics exam on Saturday! Such a bad timing, seriously.

I know so many people who have an exam actually tomorrow so they can actually enjoy the night knowing their exam is finished but mine's the next day - waaaah!

AND my brother bought me Flight of the Conchords tickets for my birthday so I cannot wait til July 7th! I actually performed one of their songs for my music assessment in Year 11 so they have a special place in my heart for those New Zealand boys. Let's hope they live up to all the expectations I have of their live shows.

Lately I've definitely been trying to have a read of the ABC news more regularly as doing these type of courses has opened my eyes to the differing quality of news between stations. Looking around the ABC website I think this: 90 Second News will definitely be something I'm checking everyday for a quick update.

In today's particular upload (as linked to above) there is a story about a Catholic priest. I always get a bit iffy when people are talking about Catholic Priests being child predators and all that. Obviously I was raised in a Catholic home and so this blurs my objectiveness substantially but EVERY single priest I've met has been nothing but kind and generous and news stories that kind of make all priests look bad gets under my skin. Obviously this particular man committed heinous crimes and I am in no way condoning his individual behaviour but the way these stories are always presented puts all Catholics in a bad light. It creates a divide and perhaps people will unfairly associate terrible things with priests when the majority are in no way deserving. Just tell the story without that focus, please!

Anyway, that's enough of my ranting. I'm gonna go prepare for this econ exam. 

:( haha. Later.


Tuesday, 17 April 2012

Lecture 7: Public Media

Public media, public media. It will be disappointing to my tutor but growing up I was pretty much only surrounded by commercial media. I hardly even watched ABC kids shows like most of my peers. I feel this, though, was the result of having three older brothers who had solid control of the TV remote throughout my childhood…haha. I feel in the past 7 weeks I’ve been at uni I’ve learnt more about public service media than I knew in the whole 17 years before I came.






So, at the start of Lecture 7 we were told that the mission of public media is to serve or engage a public. It seems in my very narrow case that it hasn’t engaged me whatsoever but I do understand the service it provides in top quality news and offering a wider diversity of programming. I know that most students enrolled in journalism have aims of working at the ABC as it seems to be one of the most respected news outlets in the country and I feel slightly disappointed that I, as of yet, have never fully exposed myself to it.
I found the list of what public media should involve pretty interesting:

  • Geographic universality
  • Universality of appeal
  • Special provision for minorities
  • Relationship to sense of national identity and community
  • Distanced from all vested interests
  • Universality of payment
  • Competition in good programming rather than competition for numbers
  • Liberate rather than restrict
From what little exposure I’ve had to the two main channels in Australia (ABC and SBS) it seems they both live up to these ‘goals’. If I’m able to bring up another class’ discussion, we were talking about how successful both the ABC and SBS have been in tailoring their programming to include ALL Australians. The result of the discussion was that the SBS are leaps and bounds ahead for minority groups whilst ABC may have some issues in their schedule looked like it was ‘designed by middle aged men for middle-aged men’ (quoted in Inglis 2006, p.476). I think that was how the ABC had always come across to me as well but after watching it more often I don’t have any difficulty enjoying its content.

I’ll move on now to the challenges that public media faces. Apparently it needs audiences. Well of course it does! After having a chat to a few of the girls that live with me, a tiny minority deliberately watch the public media channels. I think something that will be a big issue in the future for public media is the capturing of my generation as an audience. As depressing as this sounds, ABC’s and SBS’ current audience won’t be around forever and hopefully my generation will fill the gap they leave or the public sphere of the nation will be greatly disadvantaged.

Public media also have to deal with the constant scrutiny of whether or not they are politically independent. This has been a constant plague for the ABC as they have to juggle the fact that the government are the ones who fund them but their job is to be critical of them. As Dr Bruce said, it is a delicate balance when you are biting the hand that feeds you.

I followed up the point of the ABC being bias and out of all the snippets I read, this one caught my attention but mainly the few points raised at the end. ABC bias? 
It seemed pretty far-fetched to me at the beginning but then when the point that it is tax payer funded is brought up I can see how it is important that the journalists leave out their personal opinion and focus on fact. But who’s to say that this Mark Hendrickx is really telling the truth. It’s an interesting business!

Anyway I think that’ll be me done for Week 7’s lecture and now all my blogs are up to date for the assessment this Friday. J

Saturday, 7 April 2012

A Lazy Easter Leads to Contribution to ma Blog!

First things first - Happy Easter!
I'm just in the greatest mood right now. Indulging in a bit of (embarrassing) One Direction, have had a fabulous Easter morning with my fam and I've just taken my brother's dog for a walk. All doesn't seem that exciting but it really is little things that contribute to some of your best days. :)

I left college yesterday for the mid-semester break, and yes I am doing work in the holidays. Extra credit puuuhlease?

But anyway, I spent yesterday with my family in the city. Following on from my last post with a little comment on The Big Issue, my mum and I walked past a woman selling it. Now, in case you didn't know my mum is the most amazing lady! She is the kindest, most loving and sweetest thing in the whole world. She not only bought the magazine but gave extra to the lady, along with a hug and Easter wishes. I hope I can find as much generosity in my day to day life as my mum has. I'm aware that wasn't a great link to my previous post but I don't care - point is my mum is great and I love her like crazy! Haha.

Also in college news we had a car wash for St Vinnies and ended up raising over $400! Most of it earned through hassling cars off the street and forcing them into our car park...haha. And we had a send off party before the break! Interestingly the theme was St Patrick's Day which was actually a month ago...See what I mean about college making you out of sync with the outside world! Anyway it was a greeeeeeeeeeeat night and here's a sneaky pic of before we headed out:
And a girl posted this to our college Facey page, I thought it was appropriate considering the theme my blog is developing:

So I guess you know if I can't make it to class it's because it was uphill?
Nah, I'll be there every time :)

And since I've been away from home I haven't been buying as many fashion mags or sewing as much! Luckily mum has fixed this problem with delivering magazines and my machine to me so perhaps some fashion will be working its way in here as well.
I have been keeping more updated on news lately as well! Ever since that media use diary showed my shocking habits I actually have kept up a bit better. But I might save another news post til next week - gotta head out now. (:

Bye bye!

Monday, 2 April 2012

Lecture 6

Hello there!

Let’s be honest, when I was given the set reading for this week and had a look at how many pages there were…I was not keen. But after reading the first line and seeing it was about Sunrise, I was hooked! It’s my fave brekky show and I am actually EXTREMELY interested in commercial media.

After doing a mere 6 weeks of media studies (that’s a shout out to MSTU1000!) I know that commercial media is looked down upon by academics and those of high intelligence. It’s a shame to say but my TV experience has been pretty much 90% commercial, 10% public. I always knew it was driven by advertising but it wasn’t until recently that I found out how much of the actual content is driven by fact that “advertisers are the real customers”.

So in the lecture today we covered many of the major players in commercial media. There were the obvious ones, News Limited, Nine, and Ten but I never really considered Telstra and Optus ‘commercial media’. Honestly though, how could I not? They are media services with a main goal of a making a profit! I was kind of surprised at myself for not realising that earlier.

Also covered were the forms commercial media can take (subscription, sponsored and subsidised) and its three functions (commercial, propaganda and social). Some media organisations exist solely for the purpose of making money and will use whatever they can to get the most eyes/ears on their content. They do this because in the end it equals more profit for them from the advertisers! The danger of this is that quality is beginning to deteriorate. A term that was mentioned in today’s lecture was ‘Mickey Mouse News’. This pretty much sums up the idea of news being dumbed down in order to appeal to the masses. I think though, that ‘the masses’ are often underestimated. I, for example, am not of above intelligence by any means but I can still appreciate an investigative piece of journalism over a story on the best bikinis of next season. I mean, I’ll watch both haha, but the hard hitting story is the one that would really grip me.

Kind of leading to my next point that was mentioned towards the end of the lecture… While advertising revenue for commercial radio is on a steady decline, new ways of money making and business strategies will have to be created. As I’m studying a degree of Commerce/Arts this concept was of real interest to me. If I continue with my study of media there may be prospective jobs for me in the future with these commercial media companies. After completing my degree and majoring in Finance I could be dealing with this issue as part of my day to day job! Today’s consumers would be willing to pay for high quality content. It is becoming increasingly recognisable that the standard of commercial news is not absolutely fantastic and if one particular company really ramps up their game I predict a major pay day for them! Perhaps not the complete pay wall concept but just the fact that advertisers will want their stuff on the most watched (in other words, best quality) station.

I also had a quick look at the Global Mail website. I actually think THAT is a clever business idea. It’s got the quality factor that I was talking about before and I have no doubt it is going to get a strong and loyal fan base who will want to see it continue into the future. Funnily enough while looking through the stories, a piece on John Bird, the media mogul responsible for The Big Issue, caught my attention. His aims couldn’t be further away from the goals of the men and women in charge of the organisations we looked at today and I thought that was all a bit ironic.

Commercial media does have its purpose in society. It employs thousands and entertains millions. Let’s just hope a purpose is kept and that a benefit of some type to the Australian public is continued.

Thursday, 29 March 2012

A Little Update

Aaaalrighty. So at this stage I've submitted my first proper assessment for this subject! Media Use Diary is done :) I have my first mid-semester exam on Saturday for one of my Commerce subjects. It will be my first EVER uni exam so that is pretty nerve-wracking. And all the uni work is gradually starting to pile up but hopefully I'll be able to make it through...haha. After my tute for this on Tuesday afternoon I've been trying to think of topics for my Factual Storytelling Exercise. I'm pretty positive I'm going to use text but I just need someone to base that text on!

So an update on college life...food has continued to be great and I've been attempting to avoid the fresher spread by regular gym visits :) There is added motivation because my College Ball is coming up in less than a month! I've made such great pals here and at our 'brother college' so hopefully the year will continue in a positive way. College plans at the moment are perhaps a visit to the Broncos and Dragons game tomorrow night and a college 'exchange' on Saturday night. I'm struggling to maintain my work/life balance but I have no doubts that everyone is sitting in exactly the same boat.

SO, some news that gained my interest today was word of an all-girls Jewish school in New York banning their students from Facebook as it could go against the Jewish code of modesty. I found this quite extraordinary as it shouldn't be up to the school to tell girls what they can and can't do out of school! They should not be allowed to dictate the social life of these girls and prohibiting them from Facebook in such a social networking based world could do so much more harm than good. Take, for example, the low experience level the girls will have in this communication tool once they finish high school. I have no doubt that internet use will be growing exponentially and it would be such a disadvantage to the students not to have the core skills that their peers will possess. If you want to have a read of the actual news story just click here!

I'll probably write again on Monday, bye! :)

Repost of Lecture 1

Just thought I should split my Lecture 1 and 2 so here's Lecture 1, now on its own.

Lecture 1
‘You are the Journalist.’ The first lecture today pretty much just outlined the course and what we’ll be covering over the duration of JOUR1111. I feel like it’s going to be one of those courses that are worthwhile and after completing it I'll be look at everything in the media a little more critically. I will have a better understanding of what’s going on around me.

Dr. Redman made everyone feel at ease and as it was my first lecture EVER I’m not as apprehensive as I was before I entered the classroom. As of today, right after the lecture I’m still a bit unsure of what kind of stuff to blog about…Like the quotes and pictures made me think of the times that I heard big news stories breaking, for example Michael Jackson dying, Osama Bin Laden’s assassination, massacres all the world over and of course 9/11 which I remember vividly even though I was seven years old at the time. It seems that, “if it bleeds it leads” is true from my experiences.


I'd like to comment or at least reflect on each of the quotes Dr Redman included in this intro: 

  • "Journalism is the first rough draft of history." Philip Graham - I like this one because it made me think of journalism in a completely different light. You usually just think of it as up to the minute but in reality, news will pass and be replaced. So to have been able to have first comments on something that could change the world forever is a pretty big deal.
  • "Journalism can never be silent: that is its greatest virtue and its greatest fault. It must speak, and speak immediately, while the echoes of wonder, the claims of triumph and the signs of horror are still in the air." Henry Anatole Grunwald - This one has a bit more depth to it I think. I see how it is a virtue in that it is a brave and commanding area to work in. But considering the fault part, I had trouble getting my head around it. I think that maybe the fact that journalism can't be silent is a fault because there is really no time to be respectful of things that are tragic or heartbreaking. News must be covered straight away. That's really what I take away from it anyway.
  • "I became a journalist to come as close as possible to the heart of the world." Henry R. Luce - Journalism is truly about getting human reactions. I believe only the very best journalists are able to consistently get these reactions. But I do connect this quote to that opinion I hold of journalism. The whole getting to the heart of stories, gets you to the heart of the people, and really people are what makes the "world" so I see that quote as the all encompassing process of journalism.
  • "Generally speaking, the best people nowadays go into journalism, the second best into business, the rubbish into politics and the shi*s into law." Auberon Waugh - HAH, alright. I don't really like this one much. To risk being hated I think there a lot of sh*ts also in journalism. That's all I'll say on this one buddy!
  • "People may expect too much of journalism. Not only do they expect it to be entertaining, they expect it to be true." Lewis H. Lapham - I can see the point of this one. People now expect to be shocked. That's a sure fire way of getting attention and they don't get that from 'boring old news'.
  • "Journalism is organised gossip." Edward Eggleston - This is a very old one which is surprising cos I thought this would be recent and pointing the finger at current commercial news or something. I don't really agree with this one if we're talking about legit journalism which has to be based on fact. Sorry Eddy Eggy.
  • "… egomaniacs of average intelligence or less, often end up in the field of TV Journalism." Tina Fey - HAHA oh man, I luuuurve Tina Fey. Bossypants is such a good book. I had a talk by a Channel 10 GM today and he pretty much agreed with this statement. Having no personal experience I guess for now I'm agreeing until it's proven wrong to me. So come on TV journalists, fix that rep of yours. 
  • "Journalism is little more than scribbling on the back of advertisements." Anon - Phwar, harsh words. I guess commercial media's whole aim is to making money so they're going to be conscious of advertising. They're gonna need to place enough advertising in their news that they'll be able to make money. Personally I think advertisements are scribbles on news. But I know I'm pretty naive.
Hope that was what is kind of expected! Talk soon I guess :)
Image sources: Picture 1 Picture 2